|
Circus animals spend almost
their entire lives on the road, moving from one makeshift
encampment to another. Travelling for circus animals means
unbearably long hours shut up in transporters and beast
wagons. When the circus moves from one site to another,
these animals may spend up to 26 hours in their
transporters. In Greece this is likely to be even longer
with circuses having to travel from Italy and also having
to sail between islands.
Lions and tigers spend
almost all of their time in small cages on the backs of
lorries known as beastwagons. Elephants are chained for
most of the day by one front leg and one back leg. These
chains are generally only between 1.5 to 2.5 metres so an
elephant is unlikely to even be able to turn around. These
appalling conditions result in the animals becoming
psychologically disturbed and they start showing all kinds
of stereotypic behaviour, the lions and tigers constantly
pace up and down their small cages and the elephants sway
and bob their heads.
In the wild, elephants live
for up to 60 years in large family groups, constantly on
the move, travelling over 20 kilometres every day. They
enjoy bathing in watering holes and socialising. Wild
animals have been observed touching dead companions,
sometimes placing leaves and bush over the body and using
‘graveyards’.
Sick animals have to stay
on the road and pregnant animals may perform right up
until they give birth. When Circus Medrano was in Athens
young lion cubs were passed around the audience for people
to pose for photographs with.
It isn’t so much a question
of their being good or bad animal circuses. Circuses by
their very nature cannot provide for their animals
properly and should therefore not be allowed to keep them.
Animal trainers seen in the
circus ring are often presented as having developed a
loving relationship with their animals over a number of
years, training them with positive reinforcement. However,
it is common practice for animals to be supplied to
different presenters each season.
Once an animal or group has
been ‘broken’ they will probably spend the rest of their
lives performing variants of the same routine. Thus after
a while, this training becomes little more than
reinforcement. When someone sees an animal act on tour, it
is possible that the animals have been going through the
routines for five, ten or even more years right down to
the stage managed moments, for example when an animal is
supposedly wilful and refuses to obey a command. Abuse in
the form of verbal intimidation by shouting and screaming
is commonplace, as is physical abuse in the form of fists,
whips, sticks, spades, tent poles or any other implement
that might be to hand, to apply anything from a mild smack
or punch to a full-blown beating.
An animal rights group,
Animal Defenders International completed a study of
circuses, with their Field Officers obtaining jobs
undercover in circuses in various countries in Europe.
They obtained video evidence of elephants being beaten,
clubbed, kicked, punched with every imaginary weapon –
from spades, to brooms, to pitchforks, to buckets and a
wheelbarrow. Chimpanzees were kicked and beaten. Tigers
and lions were clubbed with iron bars and jabbed with
spiked tent poles.
Even large and dangerous
wild animals can be brought to a state of dependence upon
their abuser by long-term conditioning. All of the animals
that A.D.I. came across feared human beings. The tigers
and lions experienced withdrawal of food for not
performing well. All of the elephants observed by A.D.I.
were controlled by elephant hooks.
It is likely too that the
severely deprived environments in which the animals were
often housed further crushes any defiance.
Frustrated, bored and
barely able to move, circus animals steadily go out of
their minds, developing often pronounced abnormal
behaviours. There is a wide range of abnormal behaviour
identified by animal keepers and behaviourists, ranging
from ingrained, pointless repetitive movements and pacing,
head bobbing and weaving, which are developing into more
ingrained behaviours.
The CITES exemption
(Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species)
for circus allows movement of circus animals without
permits or certificates, provided certain details have
already been registered with the Management Authority and
transport arrangements are satisfactory. However, in
practice, it has not proved possible to maintain checks on
circus animals.
Circuses obtain animals
from a variety of sources; by breeding, buying and selling
between themselves, from safari parks and zoos and from
international dealers. Animals are frequently purchased or
disposed of while travelling. Currently, there is no
official system of identification for these animals.
Circuses date from a time
when psychological suffering caused by environmental
deprivation and restriction of behavioural needs were not
recognised. Circuses can continue with human acts. Animals
must not suffer for our entertainment. |